UPSC CSE Mains 2024 · PSIR Optional Paper II: all questions
Section A · Comparative Politics & International Relations
Q1(a) · Compulsory
Interpretive Approach to Comparative Politics · 10 marks · 150 words · Discuss
Discuss the interpretive approach to the study of comparative politics.
What the question asks: Explain the epistemological foundations, methodology, strengths, and limitations of the interpretive (hermeneutic) approach in comparative politics.
Q1(b) · Compulsory
World-Systems Theory · 10 marks · 150 words · Explain
Explain the central tenets of the World-Systems Theory.
What the question asks: Outline the foundational propositions, structural hierarchy, and critical limitations of Immanuel Wallerstein’s World-Systems Theory in International Political Economy.
Q1(c) · Compulsory
Russian Expansionism & “Greater Russia” · 10 marks · 150 words · Comment
The expansionist tendencies of the current Russian regime indicate its intentions for the realisation of a Greater Russia on the lines of the Soviet era. Comment.
What the question asks: Critically assess whether contemporary Russian foreign policy reflects neo-imperial revivalism toward a "Greater Russia" or defensive-realist security balancing against Western encroachment.
Q1(d) · Compulsory
Idealist Approach to International Relations · 10 marks · 150 words · Explain & Comment
Explain the various facets of the idealist approach to the study of international relations. Comment on its contemporary relevance.
What the question asks: Detail the philosophical tenets and facets of Idealism in IR, and critically evaluate its relevance in today’s turbulent, power-centric international order.
Q1(e) · Compulsory
Changing Global Order, Regional Conflicts & Disarmament · 10 marks · 150 words · Comment
The changing global order and ongoing regional conflicts, with the global powers taking sides, have jeopardised the progress made towards disarmament in the past. Comment.
What the question asks: Analyze how great-power rivalry in a transitional multipolar order and proxy-backed regional conflicts are unravelling decades of arms control and disarmament architecture.
Q2(a)
Deglobalisation vs. Globalisation · 20 marks · 300 words · Comment
“Deglobalisation is displacing globalisation.” Comment.
What the question asks: Critically evaluate whether contemporary geopolitical fragmentation, protectionism, and supply-chain reshoring represent the replacement of globalisation by deglobalisation, or its structural transformation into "re-globalisation".
Q2(b)
Post-Modern State in Advanced Capitalist Economies · 15 marks · 200 words · Analyse
What are the distinctive features of the post-modern state in the advanced capitalist economies ? Analyse.
What the question asks: Identify and critically analyse the institutional, normative, and security characteristics of the "post-modern state" in advanced capitalist democracies (especially Western Europe/EU and OECD).
Q2(c)
Limitations of NAFTA & Transition to USMCA · 15 marks · 200 words · Explain
What were the limitations of NAFTA ? How did its replacement by the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement counter them ? Explain.
What the question asks: Specify the structural, labour, digital, and dispute-settlement flaws of NAFTA (1994) and explain the concrete legal-economic innovations introduced by USMCA (2020) to address them.
Q3(a)
Global Social Movements for Women’s Physical & Bodily Rights · 20 marks · 300 words · Discuss
Discuss the major recent social movements related to the physical rights of women in various countries of the world.
What the question asks: Survey and analyse major contemporary transnational and national social movements defending women’s bodily autonomy, reproductive freedom, and protection from physical/sexual violence.
Q3(b)
Political Parties & Democratic Consolidation in Developing Societies · 15 marks · 200 words · Critically Examine
Critically examine the role of political parties in sustaining and stabilising democracies in the developing societies.
What the question asks: Evaluate both the stabilizing functions and the destabilizing pathologies of political parties in democratic consolidation across developing societies.
Q3(c)
USA, NATO & Global Hegemony · 15 marks · 200 words · Do You Agree
Do you agree with the view that the USA uses NATO as a traditional tool of strategy to perpetuate its hegemony in the world ?
What the question asks: Critically evaluate whether NATO functions primarily as a traditional US strategic instrument to maintain global hegemony, or as a mutual collective-defence alliance shaped equally by European agency.
Q4(a)
Gramscian Theory of Hegemony & Global Power · 20 marks · 300 words · Comment
“The Gramscian theory of hegemony provides many valuable insights into the nature of global power.” Comment.
What the question asks: Explain how Neo-Gramscian IR theory—adapting Antonio Gramsci—deepens our understanding of global power beyond realist military balances, while assessing its analytical strengths and limits.
Q4(b)
Decline of WTO, Trade Barriers & Economic Sanctions · 15 marks · 200 words · Discuss
The return of trade barriers and economic sanctions has diminished the spirit of GATT. In this context, discuss the factors contributing to the decline of WTO in recent times.
What the question asks: Explain how resurgent protectionism and unilateral sanctions undermine foundational GATT principles, and systematically analyse the structural and geopolitical causes of the WTO’s recent decline.
Q4(c)
European Union: Regional Integration Successes & Challenges · 15 marks · 200 words · Do You Agree & Account
Do you agree with the view that the EU has thus far proved to be the most successful experiment in the regional integration processes ? Account for its successes and also some of the recent challenges that it is faced with.
What the question asks: Assess why the European Union stands as history’s deepest regional integration model, detailing its major achievements alongside the acute internal and external challenges testing its cohesion.
Section B · India and the World
Q5(a) · Compulsory
India & UNSC Reform: Semi-Permanent vs. Permanent Without Veto · 10 marks · 150 words · Comment
“India must strive to become a semi-permanent member of the UNSC, rather than a permanent member without the right to veto.” Comment.
What the question asks: Critically evaluate the strategic trade-off for India between pursuing a "semi-permanent" UNSC seat versus accepting permanent membership without veto power.
Q5(b) · Compulsory
China–Bhutan Border Issues & India’s Security · 10 marks · 150 words · Discuss
Bhutan has historically been an ally of India, but the China-Bhutan border related issues have become a security issue for India. Discuss.
What the question asks: Explain how evolving China–Bhutan boundary negotiations and Chinese territorial claims pose acute strategic security concerns for India, and how New Delhi is responding.
Q5(c) · Compulsory
India’s Increased Clout in the WTO · 10 marks · 150 words · Discuss
“Nothing is going to move within the WTO negotiations unless India is on board.”
Discuss the main reasons behind India’s increased clout in the WTO.
What the question asks: Analyse the structural, economic, institutional, and coalition-building factors that give India decisive leverage in WTO negotiations.
Q5(d) · Compulsory
Shift from “Asia-Pacific” to “Indo-Pacific” Strategy · 10 marks · 150 words · Discuss
Discuss the rationale behind replacing the “Asia-Pacific” strategy with the new term “Indo-Pacific” strategy.
What the question asks: Explain the geopolitical, economic, and strategic rationale behind the conceptual shift from "Asia-Pacific" to "Indo-Pacific", highlighting India’s centrality and differing great-power visions.
Q5(e) · Compulsory
China’s Economic Influence in Sri Lanka & Strains in India–Sri Lanka Ties · 10 marks · 150 words · Analyse
Despite deep ties, India’s relations with Sri Lanka have seen strains due to China’s growing influence in Sri Lanka through investments and economic dominance. Analyse.
What the question asks: Analyse how China’s debt-financed infrastructure and strategic presence in Sri Lanka have strained India–Sri Lanka relations, alongside India’s recent economic and diplomatic counter-measures.
Q6(a)
Transition of India’s Foreign Policy: Nehruvianism to Neoliberalism · 20 marks · 300 words · Concur & Support
Would you concur with the view that of late, India’s foreign policy has been in a transition mode from Nehruvianism to Neoliberalism ? Support your answer with the help of suitable examples.
What the question asks: Assess whether contemporary Indian foreign policy has transitioned from Nehruvian idealism/non-alignment to neoliberal pragmatism, using concrete diplomatic and economic examples while noting enduring continuities.
Q6(b)
Feasibility of the “Asian Century” Amid India–China Friction · 15 marks · 200 words · Assess Feasibility
Does the idea of the 21st century as ‘Asian century’ continue to remain feasible given the growing friction between India and China ?
What the question asks: Evaluate whether the concept of an "Asian Century" remains viable amidst intensifying strategic, territorial, and geopolitical rivalry between Asia’s two demographic and economic giants—India and China.
Q6(c)
India as Leader of the Global South & a New International Economic Order · 15 marks · 200 words · Discuss
Discuss the potential role that India could play as the leader of the Global South in realising the goal of establishing a new international economic order in the 21st century.
What the question asks: Examine India’s strategic assets, recent initiatives, and structural limitations in leading the Global South toward a fairer 21st-century New International Economic Order (NIEO).
Q7(a)
Future of SAARC vs. ASEAN & BIMSTEC · 20 marks · 300 words · Discuss
Discuss the future of SAARC in the light of India’s increased focus on other regional groupings like ASEAN and BIMSTEC.
What the question asks: Analyse the causes of SAARC’s paralysis, India’s deliberate diplomatic pivot toward BIMSTEC and ASEAN, and the realistic future trajectory of South Asian regionalism.
Q7(b)
India’s Persistent Refusal to Sign the NPT · 15 marks · 200 words · Critically Examine
Critically examine India’s persistent refusal to sign the nuclear non-proliferation treaty (NPT) despite being recognized as a de facto nuclear power.
What the question asks: Analyse the principled, legal, and security reasons behind India’s non-accession to the NPT despite its de facto nuclear recognition, and critically evaluate the strategic trade-offs of remaining outside the treaty.
Q7(c)
India–USA: Strategic Partners, Not Formal Allies · 15 marks · 200 words · Comment
“India and USA have become such strong strategic partners that they need not become formal allies.” Comment.
What the question asks: Examine the extraordinary convergence in India–US strategic ties and explain why maintaining a non-treaty partnership suits both Washington and New Delhi better than a formal military alliance.
Q8(a)
Continuity & Change in India’s Palestine Policy (Israel–Hamas War) · 20 marks · 300 words · Critically Examine
Critically examine the continuity and change in India’s Palestine policy in the wake of the ongoing Israel-Hamas War.
What the question asks: Trace the elements of strategic shift ("change") and enduring normative commitment ("continuity") in India’s Palestine policy during the ongoing Israel–Hamas conflict, critically evaluating New Delhi’s balancing act.
Q8(b)
Scrapping the Free Movement Regime (FMR) with Myanmar & Northeast Dynamics · 15 marks · 200 words · Discuss
Discuss the implications of the scrapping of the Free Movement Regime with Myanmar by the Indian Government on the complex ethno-political dynamics of the north-eastern region.
What the question asks: Analyse the security rationale behind India’s 2024 decision to scrap the Free Movement Regime (FMR) and fence the Myanmar border, and evaluate its complex ethno-political, social, and Act East repercussions in Northeast India.
Q8(c)
From Non-Alignment to Multi-Alignment · 15 marks · 200 words · Comment
“India has of late, chosen to debunk non-alignment in its pursuit of multi-alignment.” Comment.
What the question asks: Critically evaluate the claim that India has repudiated Non-Alignment in favour of Multi-Alignment, distinguishing doctrinal style from the enduring core of strategic autonomy.